Amazing Golf Course
Toggle navigation
Home
Golf Courses
Golf Equipment
FAQs
Contact Us
Show States
Hide States
New York
Medford
Mill Pond Golf Course
Mill Pond Golf Course
50
Reviews
Reviews
Claim
Share
300 Mill Rd, Medford NY, 11763
Call now: (631) 732-8249
golfatmillpond.com
Unclaimed
Mill Pond Golf Course Reviews
Amazing Reviews:
Sort by:
Newest first
Oldest first
Best reviews
Worst reviews
Andrew Kim
Mill Pond is in excellent shape: layout, fairways and greens are great. I walked two weeks ago and it's one of my favorite tracks in Suffolk. The only challenge was the pace of play. They need marshals on the course to make sure groups don't fall behind. In my case, the cart riding group ahead was 3 holes behind and I was walking. Please help the pace of play and try to keep rounds under 4 1/2 hours.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Charlton Davenport
Had a Sweet 16 Birthday Party there and the catering and service was Awesome. Very attentive and the event went on without any bumps.... Thank You Mill Pond Staff!!!
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Nicholas Carlozzi
I am giving them a 3 but it has nothing to do with the course. Course is in excellent shape. Greens are gorgeous. The issue is the starter. Guy has an attitude and jumped on us because we brought a cooler with ice and waters. He yells at us coolers arent allowed but then goes on to say no outside alcohol is permitted. That is fine. We had water. Its 80 degrees out and it was 7am and the day was only gonna get hotter. Cart girl showed up on 11th hole. Again that is fine, but dont give me an attitude about the water I brought so I didnt collapse from heat exhaustion. Then when we are leaving starter goes out of his way to remind us we wont be allowed coolers and how he remembers every face so dont try it again. Oh yeah, still bought 6 waters from cart girl and tipped her $10. So it wasnt talking money out of her pocket. If I have to pay $81 to play a round there, I can bring my own water. That was my only issue. As I mentioned above, course was in excellent shape. Extremely well kept. If. I cant bring waters though, Ill play somewhere else.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Kevin Nicholson
The starter has a bad attitude. It was 90 degrees, high humidity and they have issues with a small cooler with water and ice. They say, 'we don't want people bringing alcohol'. Then change your policy to, no outside alcohol. Your cart girl doesn't show up until the 11th hole, so don't punish people for trying to stay hydrated.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Hiếu Như NGUYỄN
Beautiful golf course
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Ant P
Great course, not too challenging. Great mixture of greens, traps and water. Carts are awesome.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Tony
It was a nice day, greens were slower than usual. 83 dollars is a bit expensive for this course.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Tom Miller
Great course, great conditions. Recommend.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Barbara Alzate
Food is great and the hospitality is wonderful. Grounds are beautiful with some very beautiful views.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Pamela Gwathney
Nice affair a little crowded. They need a better sound system
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Stan Lightell
Nice course... Links style
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Patrick O'Connor
Well maintained and nice course to play especially during the Summer.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Adam Wilson
Golf course is in magnificent condition. Greens are fast and rolling perfectly. All staff is friendly and professional. We call it our home course and staff we call our friends.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Bobby Niski
Beautiful day, course is in excellent condition
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Robert Clougher
Very nice venue. Reasonable prices for large parties.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Gordon Lenz II
This course is always in great shape. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. A public course with a country club feel
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Andrew Nawrocky
Very nice golf course
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Annmarie Burke
Beautiful place friendly staff great service good food, all are welcome.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Brian Barry
Went for a Sweet 16. Nice place
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
patrick healy
We caterd our company Christmas party there last year and this year,they do a good job, and have a cash barPS I don't play golf
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Steven Seligman
We only stopped by to use the practice facility but it looked like an excellent course. The club house was very nice.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Andy Logan
Recommend highly. Used them 3x. Very satisfied. Great prices. Willing to work with you to make a customized and wonderful experience.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Rob Upson
Nice people throughout, discount card available for Brookhaven residents. Course is interesting and challenging, tees and greens in good shape. Enclosures on carts this time of year (December) would be nice but otherwise a great place to play. They have a substantial driving range and a decent purring green. I play here often and always enjoy it. One note, after ant period of heavy rain there are no carts allowed on the course. It's understandable but the course is, in my opinion anyway, a tough walk.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Bill
Nice course
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Steven Perrone
Rented the electric walking cart that follows you,the thing is awesome,made the round more fun,course in great shape
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
George E. Williams
Complimentary clubs and balls for driving range....thank you Aleshia.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
JoAnn Armstrong
Amazing Chef Armstrong, serves up the best food items.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Natasha Tracy
It being my boyfriend whom plays the course and speaks VERY HIGHLY of its EXCELLENCE.....What greater than a purchase of an AFFORDABLE ROUND ON ITS PRISTINE GREENS. I got ahead of THE GAME FOR THE GREAT HOLIDAY GIFT GIVING...(HOWEVER, GREAT IDEA FOR ANY GIFT GIVING , OR JUST TO SAY I LOVE YOU...TO THE MAN YOU LOVE )..... I LOVE IT!!!SURELY I KNOW.....HELl LOVE IT AS WELL!!
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Jason Collins
The track is good, but some holes can be somewhat tight. The par 3s will challenge your iron shots. One hole the the box plays right up against homes which is nice.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Steven Piccirillo
Very clean and well maintained. The only issue was club house closed early and vending machines weren't working
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Peter De Shields
Great condition all the way through. Short but difficult. Rarely a flat stable lie. Nobody rakes the sand traps. If you play in the afternoon. Stay out if the sand. Always challenging rough. Bring balls to spare.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Francis Rudegeair
I haven't play the course for a few years and after my game today I don't know why. It's on my to play again before the summer is over
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
MICHAEL GOEHLE
Great course par 70 open concept wide fairways
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Robert Pascalli
Always in great shape.course play is always fast ..fast greens fast fairways..greens roll true and fairways are lush..hidden gem in suffolk county..
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Nathanel Levi
Lots of fun
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Marielena Arroyo
Justcame back today 6/4/19from a group lunch at Mill Pond in Medford NY and what a disappointment! Menu extremely limited, mostly salads with chicken or tuna and that was not very good and small for an entree. Desert, nothing to choose from cookies or a brownie and thats it. Will not goback; too bad, place is nice!
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
John Johnson
Always in great shape especially for a public course.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
scott perez
Course was in great condition. Greens just a touch rocky in some spots, medium fast speed. Welcoming staff and starter. Included a free round for future use.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Sal DiDomenico
Great shape... plays quick.... and inexpensive!!!
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Debra Scarfogliero
Food n service was spectacular
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Griffin Schlesinger
Terrible golf course. Everything is uneven. Grass in horrific condition. The fairways are uneven. There is no flat land. Even spot your ball ends up, is an uneven stance lie. Even the tee box is uneven. Not very consistent since you cant even stand straight on any shot.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Kristopher Selden
Went for a cub scout blue and gold ceremony. the staff did a great job and the food was good.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
William S
Mill Pond is a favorite course. Excellent green conditions, super friendly staff (from grabbing your clubs from your car to easy start), and an overall fun experience. Depending on how you manage the fescue and the wind, you can score on most holes if played smart. Expect a long round time if windy.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Paul May
nice course well-kept for winter. lots of interesting features without being gimmicky.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Irene Malfa
Charlotte always goes above and beyond to make sure every event is wonderful. The food and service are top-notch. The venue is beautiful. Charlotte takes care of everything down to the smallest detail. She is such a pleasure to work with!
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Kevin Gal
Great course difficult but good
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Richard Cunniffe
Beautiful driving range and club house. Haven't played the course yet.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
John F
Beautiful Sunday day so gave 3 stars instead of lower. Slow play 5 hours to play plus tee time delayed for 25 minutes. Cart shortage and this was at 930am. Pretty odd that was the case. Robin was great.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Robert Clougher
Excellent food. Great prices. Looking forward to booking a party.
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Eileen Rosskamp
Very nice Food was good and the service was excellent, bathroom was clean, and the drinks where excellent Would recommend to any one for all kinds of parties or weddings. Plenty of parking also
Reply
An error occured, please try again later.
Rate and Review Your Experience
Please select at least one star!
Send your review
An error occured, please try again later.
Nearby Amazing Golf Courses
Fairway Golf Management
300 Mill Rd, Medford, NY 11763
...
Blue Ridge Golf Club
899 Golf Ln, Medford, NY 11763
...
Spring Lake Golf Club
30 E Bartlett Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
...
Middle Island Country Club
275 Yaphank Middle Island Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
...
Pine Ridge Golf Club
2 Golf Course Dr, Coram, NY 11727
...
Willow Creek Golf & Country Club - NY
1 Clubhouse Dr, Mt Sinai, NY 11766
...
Search By State
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
Loading, please wait...
Loading, please wait...
Loading, please wait...