Fairport, New York
Reviews
50 reviews
Terry McArdle
Perfect course if you love informality, easygoing camaraderie, and relatively forgiving open spaces. If you're looking for something by Robert Trent Jones, look elsewhere. if you're looking for a good time with good friends and not a whole lot of golf pressure, check this place out.
Craig McKown
We usually go to Island Valley for the laid back (no pressure) atmosphere. For the same reason most people do? My daughter joined me today, she doesn't golf at all, but wanted to hang out... noone at the Shed to check in with. But we signed in and went on our way. On the second hole the guy working chased us down to see if we paid. (Totally understandable.) But gave me a hard time that I didn't pay an extra fee for her to ride with me. (I said I'd pay that) 'no it's okay this time.' At the end of the round the same guy told me that she needed to be 21 to drive the cart, and to not let her drive again! 'If my boss sees that he would kick us off the course.'I don't know if I'm in the wrong for letting my 16year old daughter drive a golf cart but it seems like the wrong place to be discouraging future business??
Bartholomew Price
Owner is rude and is super creepy. Keep kids and loved ones far away!
shorty6100
A bit expensive. Not appropriately priced compared to other courses in Monroe County. Course generally not in good shape. Staff much friendlier than in the past. Their used to be a very rude and confrontational employee cutting grass, but I no longer see him. If play is slow, chances are no one will allow you to play through. Golf etiquette is a rarity here. I spend time repairing people's divots. Why do I play here? It is generally not busy, and I usually can get in a quick 9 holes. Good course to walk. I'm originally from Fairport and spent senior high school skip day here.
Timothy Haggerty
A challenging course...tight fairways, large terrain changes, large greens...but slow today. A good course for a cart. Very humid when I played...bounded tightly by trees.
